Carols and Confusions

Christmas carol singing in January? Unusual timing. Then again, all sorts of strange things happen in our corner of France. When our French friend, Camille, asked me to join in, I agreed, dragging my reluctant husband, Jack, along with me.
Five churches are involved in the celebration. A small choir assembles at church one, where a short repertoire of well-known carols is sung. The choristers, plus audience supporters, drive to the next church. This continues in an ever-increasing convoy to the last church. At least, that’s the plan.

We have since learned that the massed crowds could be even larger, but there are casualties en route. Some folks get lost, others go to the wrong church, and sung-out singers who can’t squeeze out any more notes throw in the towel and go home.
Jack and I arrived for the pre-concert practice, and as the commune ‘anglaises’, we were instantly earmarked to sing a duet anglais.
As with many community activities in our village, the rehearsal was predictably shambolic and rife with tantrums, this time between several wannabe conductors over who should take charge of the baton. Jack found the entire proceedings horrifyingly but manfully held his tongue. We struggled through, and the eventual performances were spirited rather than skilled.
Much to Jack’s secret relief, for a couple of years, covid prevented any further choral outbreaks. This year was different. Newly elevated to churches carol singing organiser, Camille gave me the happy news that we were back in business. Unfortunately, I had a packed day, but I could sing at our church. Jack predictably discovered an urgent appointment (coward) and gave his apologies.
Turning up at our church for the rehearsal, I said ‘bonjour’ to established choir members and was introduced to new faces. “I’m ninety-five,” chirruped a minute person, shoving her way to the front. I knew I was going to like this lady. We gathered, ready to sing.
Madame Benadeau, a rival team leader from a different church, checked her list and frowned. “Where is Madame Calcatt?” she demanded. Camille surveyed faces. “Can someone call her?” “She still doesn’t have a phone,” grumped Madame Benadeau. Jean-Pierre, the church verger, pew cleaning nearby, was despatched to find madame.
Flipping through endless music sheets, Momo, an eccentric chum, sidled up to me. She pointed at a carol. “Is this it?” she hissed, showing me a different song to mine. Camille gave us a stern look, ignored our confusion and launched into Mon Beau Sapin all by herself. Nobody had that one. We searched for new song sheets and eventually caught up in various keys.
“I’m ninety-five,” peeped a voice at the end of verse one. Little madame was still in fine fettle.
We were about halfway through the rehearsal when the door was flung open. All of a fluster, in rushed Madame Calcatt. She had been cleaning windows and forgotten about our practice. Heads wagged. This was very bad form. Camille, deeply disappointed, sighed and turned to me. I’d been assigned a solo ‘en anglais’, and it was my turn. I yodelled through Once in Royal David’s City. It’s a universal favourite, so I hoped the others might join in. Sadly not.
“Since you can only come to our church,” said Camille when I had finished, “you can sing another. Which will it be?” Everyone beamed approvingly at me. This was a shock. “How about the Coventry Carol?” I stammered, desperately trying to think of a shortie. “The only thing is,” I added, “the carol is very sad and refers to Herod and his terrible deeds.” Camille, who is deeply religious, tutted impatiently. “Never mind,” she said. “Nobody will understand you anyway. It’ll be fine. Sing it now.”
Performance day finally arrived, and I turned up to an empty church. Surviving singers and supporters started straggling in. Our choir, still not enormous, was now twice the size. Camille bustled up with a scarf tightly coiled up to her eyes. She’d come down with le rhume (a cold). It occurred to me that singing through all that wool might be tricky.
Sniffing noisily, Camille distributed yet more song sheets. “Where’s Senora Marybelle?” she whispered. “She’s supposed to be singing a solo!” With the congregation seated and waiting, there was no time to worry. As we arranged ourselves into a line, Momo nudged me. “I’ve found another anglais!” she proudly squeaked, pointing at an alto. It sounded like an archaeological discovery. “Do you know her?” she added. (As the token anglaises in our community, everyone naturally assumes we know every single English person in the area.) Sadly, not true. I had no idea who she was.
Our performance went much as expected. Sung at various tempos and with two conductors at one point, we rattled through the first set of carols. Senora Marybelle, who had gone to the wrong church, was now with us and ready to sing her solo. We settled down to listen.
A petite lady with bags of enthusiasm, Marybelle set off with great verve in completely the wrong key. Her chosen piece was a challenging arrangement of Ave Maria involving trills and extra-high notes. Stoically ignoring the fact that the top notes were now far higher than any human might reasonably be capable of hitting, she carried on regardless.
There wasn’t a sound from the assembled company as she heroically battled higher and higher, valiantly stabbing at those punishingly high notes. We winced, breathing with her as she fought the trills. Having a couple of emergency breaths and clenching/unclenching fists in the middle seemed to help. And it was a long, long piece, but she made it. Relieved applause rang around the church. This had been an impressive effort.
We gathered for our grand finale. It was Hark the Herald Angels, and the congregation was encouraged to sing along. By the time we reached the final verse, the church was vibrating with many different tunes. Our carol concert was coming to a triumphal conclusion, so brilliant that we ended with an encore of the chorus complete with an inventive descant. It was a couple of lines from the end when, with no warning at all, the church was plunged into darkness. This was a first.
As shocked singers fizzled out, our mayor came to the rescue by firing up his mobile phone. Using its light, he strode down the aisle, up the steps to the organ loft and fiddled with switches. Worries about a disapproving divine intervention were dispelled as the church was once again bathed with light. No problem, the electricity metre just needed a tweak.
Following the final carol service performance, a spread is always provided by the host village. Sadly, I couldn’t stay and left as trestle tables were being laid with tureens and many galette des rois, kings’ cakes (a puff pastry cake with a small charm hidden inside, traditionally eaten during Epiphany). As I said my goodbyes, clear as a bell, one voice rose above all the others. “I’m ninety-five, you know.” It had been another classic experience, one of those that make life here so special.
Postscript
Just to let you know that Fat Dogs and Welsh Estates was published on the 12th of January. I sincerely hope you enjoy my Welsh tales. The reviews the book is currently receiving are incredibly heartwarming and will make a huge difference to its success. Thank you so much for your fantastic support!
4th February 2023 @ 2:17 pm
What a beautiful church. I love the (are they?) mosaics decorating the walls. How old is the church? Perhaps you could write something about its history? The nativity scenes are beautiful too.
5th February 2023 @ 6:58 am
I included photos from several of the churches, Heather. Actually, the one you’re thinking about is covered in murals and is very beautiful. Yours is a super idea, especially since its history is fascinating, I’ll share the story in a future blog.
5th February 2023 @ 4:00 pm
Thank you for giving me an all-out laugh in these chilly days. Beautiful churches and loony people (in the nicest possible way)
6th February 2023 @ 8:35 am
I’m glad it gave you a giggle. Singing in these beautiful churches is a joy. And, yes, we wouldn’t be without our enchantingly eccentric friends.
6th February 2023 @ 2:51 pm
This is such a fun blog Beth, I love the beautiful churches and the marvellously eccentric variety of choristers and conductors! As an alto I winced at the performance of Ave Maria – it just made me giggle! Well done for singing those solos. The Coventry Carol isn’t an easy one. We have sung it several times and it’s one of my faves! What a wonderful tradition though, going singing in different churches collecting singers as you go along!
6th February 2023 @ 5:38 pm
I’m so glad you enjoyed it, Rebecca, there genuinely isn’t a dull moment! The poor lady singing Ave Maria. It was the most technically complex version, and she really did struggle, bless her. Ah, thank you. I decided on the Coventry Carol because it’s short and a beautiful, melodic piece. I love the tradition, and as you’ll imagine, the acoustics in each of the churches are different. It’s an absolute joy to be part of.
7th February 2023 @ 2:31 pm
Love all of your books and the blog. My wife Aline and I share your love for animals and like reading about your beautiful dogs and the critters on your French estate. Please keep writing and we will keep reading.
7th February 2023 @ 4:10 pm
With support like yours, Merlin, I’m happy to carry on sharing our tales. Thank you so much for being such kind, stalwart supporters.
1st April 2023 @ 7:59 pm
I absolutely love this story Beth and could just imagine all the confusion trying to get everyone to the right churches at the right time, but it sounds like a great fun evening was had by all. 😁 Those churches are beautiful and those windows are gorgeous! 💕
2nd April 2023 @ 7:45 am
Thank you, I’m so glad you enjoyed the story, Lorraine. There was lots of confusion, terrible singing and, yes, many folks go to the wrong churches. Still, it really is a great event and a lovely example of how our community comes together. 🙂 x
3rd April 2023 @ 8:20 am
Let me *chime* in that I, too, would love to know more about this church – so unprepossessing from the exterior and a riot of color on the interior.
I’m sure the acoustics were lovely and wish you had made a vid of your solo!
3rd April 2023 @ 8:25 am
Thank you for chiming in, Jemille! Each of the churches has a special charm. I promise to write a blog about the one with all the murals. You’re right, the acoustics are wonderful. I adore singing in churches, though rarely take videos!